Reports of More Icebergs Are Misleading

Reports of More Icebergs Are Misleading
February 1, 2003

S. Fred Singer

Dr. S. Fred Singer, an atmospheric and space physicist, is one of the world's most respected and... (read full bio)

Contrary to opinions held by some researchers, a new analysis of more than 20 years of historical data has found no evidence that the increasing number of large icebergs off Antarctica’s coasts is a result of global warming trends.

“The dramatic increase in the number of large icebergs as recorded by the National Ice Center database does not represent a climatic change,” said Brigham Young University electrical engineering professor David Long, who, with Cheryl Bertoia of the U.S. National Ice Center, reports these findings in a recent issue of EOS Transactions, a publication of the American Geophysical Union. “Our reanalysis suggests that the number of icebergs remained roughly constant from 1978 to the late 1990s.”

“Dr. Long’s analysis shows that the increase is only an ‘apparent increase,’ and that it is premature to think of any connection between this kind of iceberg (growth) and global warming,” said Douglas MacAyeal, a University of Chicago glaciologist who tracks icebergs. “His research, particularly with his amazing ability to detect and track icebergs, is really the best method” for determining the actual rate of the creation of icebergs. Using BYU’s supercomputers, Long enhanced images of the waters around Antarctica transmitted by satellite. Comparing that data to records from the federal government’s National Ice Center, which tracks icebergs larger than 10 miles on one side, he determined previous tracking measures were inadequate, resulting in a gross undercounting. An additional recent spike in large icebergs can be explained by periodic growth and retraction of the large glaciers that yield icebergs every 40 to 50 years, he said, noting previous research done by other scientists. Long is careful to distinguish between the birth of large icebergs and the widely publicized collapse of the Larsen B ice shelf last year, which yielded many smaller icebergs. Other scientists have clearly shown, Long said, that event was the result of localized warming. Referring to his current study, Long said, “This data set is not evidence of global warming. Nor does it refute global warming.” Long and his student assistants have pioneered the use of images generated from the SeaWinds-on-QuikSCAT satellite for tracking icebergs. The NASA satellite carries a device called a scatterometer, which measures wind speed and direction by recording the reflection of radar beams as they bounce off ocean waves. Until recently, the resolution of the images generated by the scatterometer was too low to distinguish icebergs. Long’s team developed a computer processing technique that produces images sharp enough to reliably track icebergs. The BYU group has been working with the National Ice Center since 1999, when Long rediscovered a massive iceberg, the size of Rhode Island, threatening Argentine-shipping lanes. The Ice Center had lost track of it because of cloudy skies.

Source: D.G. Long et al., “Is the number of icebergs really increasing?” Eos 83, No. 42, October 24, 2002.


S. Fred Singer, professor emeritus of environmental sciences at the University of Virginia and president of the Science and Environmental Policy Project, shares his thoughts on environment and climate news stories of the month. Singer’s The Week That Was columns can be found at www.sepp.org.

S. Fred Singer

Dr. S. Fred Singer, an atmospheric and space physicist, is one of the world's most respected and... (read full bio)