Is the IRS Rescheduling the Death of the Dollar?
Ever since President Obama signed the ill-conceived “Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act” (FATCA) into law in 2010, I’ve been warning about the death of the dollar.
And I haven’t been alone. Other experts have cautioned about FATCA’s potential to literally shut down the global economy when it goes into full effect July 1. But the IRS has now postponed that day of reckoning – for at least some – until January 1, 2016.
The idea behind FATCA is simple: Demand that other countries enforce America’s imperialistic tax laws. And to do so by the confiscation of foreign assets, if necessary.
Under the provisions of FATCA, interest, dividends, rents, and similar payments leaving the United States will be subject to a 30 percent withholding tax. The only way that most foreign banks and other foreign companies will be able to avoid this tax is to act as unpaid IRS informants. Foreigners investing in the U.S. will be affected, too. If their foreign bank isn’t FATCA compliant, their U.S. income will get whacked by 30 percent. It will be possible to recover the tax in some cases, but even so, I can’t think of a better way to scare foreign investors away from the U.S.
Something I call “FATCA contagion” would be even worse. In this scenario, because they couldn’t be completely certain that foreign recipients are FATCA compliant, U.S. banks might start routinely deducting 30 percent from international funds transfers – and letting the IRS sort it all out.
You can probably imagine what this might do to the value of the U.S. dollar. It could sink like a stone. If there’s panic selling out of the dollar, the U.S. Treasury could impose foreign exchange controls overnight. If it went on for more than a day or two, it would shut down much of the global economy.
The IRS seems to have become dimly aware of this possibility. On May 2, it released regulations that give many of the companies and financial institutions affected by FATCA another 18 months – until January 1, 2016 – to become fully compliant. But this extension will apply only if the IRS thinks the particular institution is making a “good-faith effort” to do so. If it’s not, withholding begins July 1.
How is any U.S. bank supposed to know if the foreigner to whom it’s sending money has made a good-faith effort to become an IRS spy? Sure, the IRS has exempted entire categories of foreign recipients from the withholding tax, and others will be “deemed compliant” if they just try to comply.
Entire countries are labeled “compliant” if they sign what the IRS calls a “Model 1” FATCA agreement. This requires that banks in those countries send the information demanded by the IRS to their own tax authorities to subsequently be sent to the IRS.
But because it’s expensive to set up a FATCA compliance program, thousands of what the IRS calls “foreign financial institutions” or “non-financial foreign entities” have made no effort to become FATCA compliant. Unless the IRS delays the withholding mandate entirely, there’s a real potential for disaster.
I don’t have a reputation as a fear-monger. But FATCA has me very worried. The only way the IRS can stave off the possible collapse of the U.S. dollar after July 1 is to delay withholding for everyone until January 1, 2016.
Don’t get me wrong… I’m pleased that the IRS made a halting step away from the dollar precipice. But it’s already too late to avoid stepping over it eventually. Here’s why:
Decline of ‘Dollar Imperialism’
To many foreigners, FATCA was simply the last straw. They’re fed up with what many are calling “dollar imperialism.” America is already the world’s largest debtor. Our government owes more money to more people than anyone else in the world. And in just the last seven years, our nation’s central bank has created $4 trillion out of thin air through quantitative easing. If you or I tried that trick, we’d go to jail for counterfeiting.
And now FATCA.
In response, the rest of the world is finally setting up the financial and contractual infrastructure to avoid the dollar entirely. That’s a big reason China has signed agreements calling for the use of its currency, the yuan, in financial exchanges with numerous major countries including Germany, Russia, and India. Japan and India have signed a currency deal linking their currencies closer together. Saudi Arabia and other oil-producing states in the Middle East plan to end dollar-for-oil exchanges and instead settle deals with a basket of non-U.S. currencies and gold.
All these arrangements, and many more, lessen the world’s dependency on U.S. dollars. FATCA only accelerates this process, and delaying FATCA will merely delay disaster. There’s no way to stop it. Even if the dollar doesn’t collapse shortly after July 1, the handwriting is on the wall. The dollar is doomed.
It’s time to start thinking about Plan B for your assets. Today couldn’t be too soon.
Mark Nestmann (firstname.lastname@example.org) is president and CEO at The Nestmann Group, Ltd. Used with permission of Nestmann.com.